What you'll find at
Bloomington's Hometown Jeweler
403 South College Avenue
Bloomington, Indiana 47403
(812) 332-2676

Being an independent jeweler gives us infinite choices in what we can offer. Our biggest restriction is the physical size of our showroom, so we pack it with styles ranging from classic to contemporary. We ARE the small store with the big selection!

Settle Jewelry is very much a "bricks and mortar" retailer, with no immediate plans to add e-commerce to our variety of services, but we invite you to preview selections from some of our favorite vendors. MUCH more is in store, and if you don't see it, please ask. We are here for you!

The best built performance sport watch...period. A bold claim, but Reactor backs it up with style and a unique set of features that create a new standard for durability in the watch industry. Learn more (and watch some fun videos) by clicking on the Reactor logo, or see the collection close-up at our authorized dealership.


We need our loved ones to be close to us; we need to feel their touch. With First Impressions jewelry, your loved ones are never far away; you can be reminded of their touch always! Now you can capture precious fingerprints in silver or gold. The process is simple and only takes seconds. The result is a keepsake that will be treasured for generations. First Impression styles include pendants, bracelet beads, rings, tie tacks, money clips, cuff links, and golf ball markers. All styles include engraved personalization, and pendants can be customized with diamond or birthstone bails.

ArtCarved Bridal has been making weddings special since 1850. Much has changed since then, but not the high standard of quality which has made ArtCarved wedding rings world famous - more brides and grooms select ArtCarved wedding rings than any other brand! Engagement sets are made to order, with your choice of metal, center stone size and shape, and to your finger size. ArtCarved wedding bands are backed by The Forever Warranty™, assuring against imperfection in design, materials or workmanship forever, and if your size ever changes, ArtCarved will resize or replace your wedding band free of charge (only a small processing and shipping fee applies). Choose from 14 or 18 karat gold, platinum, or palladium for engagement sets. All those metals plus titanium and tungsten carbide are available in ArtCarved wedding band styles.

Designed for today's man, Triton is the ultimate jewelry collection that fuses inspired artistry, innovative engineering, and contemporary metals to create bold statements. Strength meets style, backed by master craftsmanship and uncompromising attention to detail - because it's the details that make the man. Bold styles. Masculine metals. Triton.

Time flies. Bulova soars! For more than 125 years, the name Bulova has symbolized a uniquely American blend of old-world craftsmanship and new-world innovation. Bulova firsts include: the first company to introduce full lines of men's and women's wristwatches (post WWI), the world's first clock radio (1928), and the first timepiece on the moon (1969). As a marketing pioneer, Bulova sponsored the first national radio commercial in 1926 ("At the tone it's 9 pm B-U-L-O-V-A, Bulova watch time"), and the world's first television commercial in 1941 ("America runs on Bulova time" at the start of a Dodgers/Phillies game). Be a winner in the race against time- choose a Bulova!

Why spend a fortune on fresh flowers only to have them wilt in a few days? Now you can give a real long-stemmed rose that will last forever. Our core collection consists of a gold dipped rose and eight others that are first lacquered to preserve the original petal color then trimmed in gold. Twelve new varieties that mimic birthstone colors are our newest addition (the "diamond" and "opal" are pretty spectacular!). We also have miniature roses in the form of a stick pin or brooch, and a limited supply of orchids with the purple and white blossoms trimmed in gold. VERY affordable, and VERY beautiful!  H-m-m-m. Jewelry and flowers. Now, if we could only fit a chocolate factory in our back room! From mid-November to the end of the year we offer gold-dipped ornaments for your holiday tree. New for 2013 is a gold-dipped sand dollar, which joins mistletoe, holly leaves, a starfish, and more. All real, all really glittery for the season.

Today's charms...tomorrow's heirlooms. Let the miniature works of art by Rembrandt Charms commemorate special moments and interests in your loved one's life, or your own! With dozens of categories and thousands of available styles (we carry over 200 for immediate gifting), you are sure to find the perfect way to symbolize those treasured memories. And now you can "Create a Charm Bracelet" online! Choose a metal, choose your bracelet style, select charms by category or keyword, click and drag to place them on the bracelet, and print out the finished design, complete with style numbers and an estimated total cost. Then simply bring us the printout to place your order. How could it be easier?

No more struggling to hide the clasp when it is the focal point of your Convertible Clasp Bracelet, the perfect balance of fashion and fun. Choose your starter bracelet, available in sterling silver, 14 karat yellow gold, or two-tone, then change the clasp to fit your mood, the season, or whatever suits your fancy. Each lets you tell a personal story, one that you can change anytime you want. Click on the LeStage logo for a preview, or come in and try some on!

Rego Manufacturing, like Settle Jewelry, is family-owned and operated. Their contemporary and classic styles, along with quality and service we can always depend on, are reasons we choose to carry so many of their beautiful diamond and gemstone pieces. Have a custom design in mind? Rego specializes in special orders, aided by their state-of-the-art 3D modeling machine and skilled technicians and customer service personnel.

Stuller is one of the world's leading manufacturers of fine jewelry, mountings, and repair components. Have you been thinking about restyling some out-of-fashion or worn out jewelry? Let our remount experts lead the way! Overnight service is available for many ready-to wear jewelry fashions, so don't fret when your loved one decides on the perfect accessory with no time to spare. Stuller to the rescue!

Settle Jewelry is the exclusive major regional retailer of the Ear Pin, a unique jewelry fashion that gives the illusion of defying gravity by gently following the curves of the earlobe. Ear Pins are extremely comfortable, with no clumsy hardware needed to hold them in place. Available to fit any budget, Ear Pin styles range from sterling silver to 14 karat white or yellow, two-tone, or rose gold, with many gemstone possibilities. They can even be worn by those without pierced ears - making them perfect for those who choose not to pierce, or even for your little girl's dress-up occasions. Another innovation by the makers of The Ear Pin are Ear Spirals. Haven't seen them yet? Wait no longer! Visit the manufacturer's website by selecting the Ear Pin logo, or visit Settle Jewelry's extensive selection in person and buy at a lower price than ordering direct!

The J. P. Knight Company believes that fine jewelry is a lifetime investment. They built their reputation on cutting top-quality diamonds. Now, with three generations of family ownership, integrity, and expertise, J. P. Knight offers a variety of finished jewelry with diamonds and various colored gemstones.

Give her the gift that's always in fashion and will always be remembered. Add-A-Pearl necklaces start with a single pearl or small strand. As each memory passes you add another pearl until the necklace is complete. Available in natural and cultured pearls.

Defining the 21st century renaissance woman, Vanna K presents a new sense of style for a new generation. Using 18 karat white gold, sometimes accented with pink or yellow gold, Vanna K's designs are fresh and contemporary, yet reminiscent of designs of yesteryear. You'll see micro-pavé, filigree, milgrain, and more in Vanna's jewelry sculptures.

Speidel has continued to set the standard for functional, fashionable replacement watchbands since the introduction of the Twist-O-Flex nearly 50 years ago. Now offering leather watch bands from alligator to ostrich to shark (and even PVC, nylon, and silicone), Speidel will help you stay connected. We also carry a wide selection of Speidel Medilog bracelets and necklaces to help safeguard you through unexpected health emergencies.

What good is a once-beautiful gemstone that has lost its dazzle to soap film and hand lotion? Kingswood to the rescue! Restore the original brilliance to your treasured diamonds and most precious gemstones with a quick bath in Fine Jewelry Cleaner. Settle Jewelry also carries other Kingswood jewelry care products. See us for Silver Jewelry Cleaner (an excellent tarnish remover), Fine Jewelry Cleaner (for delicate and porous stones), and Jewelry Polishing Cloths (to restore the metal's luster). Be sure to ask for a checkup of your jewelry while you're here. We'll look for loose stones, worn settings, weak connections, and other dangers to the safety and security of your treasured heirlooms. It only takes a few minutes, and it's FREE!